The Grand Narrative’s First Birthday
( Source )
Apologies for not writing this post on the day, but then the combination of viruses on my laptop and the week-long flu I had didn’t exactly lend themselves to injecting some bonhomie into what I was writing. Also, I confess, blogging-wise I’d been feeling a bit wistful anticipating the blog’s first birthday, much like I find one’s own actual birthday arriving is usually a bit of a let-down here because of the bizarre Korean habit of adding a year to your age on January the first, regardless of how late in the year the actual date is.
Enough of that though. Lots to talk about, and probably much too honestly for my own good. I’ll start with the blog’s statistics, as much of what I plan to do with it in the next year (or largely not do as it turns out) ultimately revolves around those. Sorry if the following sounds like so much navel-gazing on my part, and/or only of interest to other bloggers, but then there won’t be another post like it for another year!
Statistics
Here they are for the last three months:

And please allow me some vanity by presenting this graph from when I started using StatCounter also:

Some blogging milestones difficult to make out in those are my reaching 1000 visitors for the first time on the 13th May, and having over 1000 visitors a day every since June the 8th. I was tempted to extend the stats one day further, because then I reached a new record of 1269 visitors, but that would be cheating.
Okay, stats both should and shouldn’t be important to bloggers that don’t have advertisements on their sites. They should because:
- Boy, does looking at that second graph feel good. Seriously though, short of the much more important but intangible networking, employment and other goals I aimed for by setting up the blog, there’s little else, other than numbers of links, comments and RSS feed subscribers, to tell you that what you’re writing is actually being read and discussed.
- Many may disagree, but I do think that the day a blogger stops caring about his or her stats is the day the quality of their blog begins deteriorating. For sure, there are natural ceilings to the numbers of people that will read blogs about Korea, especially pretentious ones with long posts like mine, and after, say, five years of blogging then I may well not give a rat’s ass about stats either. But in the meantime, there are a host of small and trivial-sounding but ultimately important changes you can make to a blog to make both first-time and long-term readers enjoy it and want to come back, and a good place to start learning about those is this blog about, well, blogging. The content is still very important of course, but it’s little good if people can’t find your blog easily, or get so put off by, say, a disorganized layout once they’re there that they can’t be bothered reading it.
- The more popular your blog is, the more likely people are to find it. I’ll be the first to admit that I’ve written some complete crap on my blog, and on many occasions have seriously considered deleting the entire thing and starting with a fresh slate because of it. But now that this gratuitous shot of Miss Korea is up for example, then the thousands of people who’ve googled it and arrive at this blog via that route mean that my blog gets pushed up higher in the results of the more “serious” searches that I want, even though those googling, say, Neo-Confucianism Korea Women, may be less than impressed by those pictures lurking elsewhere in the blog. Because of the former I’d be foolish to remove them, but because of the latter I’d be stupid to highlight them too, so I’m in a bind over whether to remove the “Hot Korean Girls” category or not.
Similarly, if I went self-hosting – as I promised to do once I reached 1000 visitors a day – then I’d be back at square one in the searches, and as that one negative more than outweighs the minor positives then I’ve decided against it. Sorry.
( Image by PeterForret )
But that last point about Miss Korea leads me to why I also shouldn’t care about my stats:
- The more visitors I get, the more Statcounter tells me that the vast majority looked for less than five seconds. In my friend’s experience, if he’s looking for pictures of women via google than it takes, hell, a good ten seconds or so to determine that a site like this one has very few pictures of women really, and that they’re wearing entirely too many clothes. But still, five or ten seconds or whatever, on a good day 80% of my visitors are doing anything but reading it. That has nothing to do with how good or bad my blog is – it seems to be inherent to popular blogs, especially ones that mention women in virtually any capacity – but still, it places the statistics in some perspective.
- The number of links to your blog are more important then. Unfortunately Technorati, the best-known site which measures those, is very unreliable, regularly counting splogs that link here as genuine but missing whole swathes of links from genuine blogs entirely. But presumably it’s missing out links to other blogs too, so while the absolute figures it provides are useless the relative figures if provides are okay. Which means that Brian’s excellent blog, for instance, gets far fewer hits than mine but is much better known and talked about (just!). As he himself is, given his articles in various Korean magazines and newspapers, and is setting an example I plan to follow.
Practicalities
Time, Comments
Even just three months ago, I usually spent about 1-2 hours a day on the blog, mostly basking in the glory of my stats reluctantly rejecting topics to blog about, reading books and journal articles on those I did choose, writing and editing, and finally finding cool photos on Flickr. These days, it’s usually 3-4, primarily because I’m doing all that and responding to comments, emails, and unfortunately a large and increasing number of trolls too.
I hope I’ll never become like some big name Korea bloggers that virtually ignore all comments and emails, but I’d be lying if I said that I sometimes feel weary dealing with all of them these days. Until recently I generally worked on posts and research in the mornings, went to work at about lunchtime, and then dealt with comments when I arrived home at 10:30, but these days if I gave all of them the replies that they deserved then I’d be up till 2am most nights. Sometimes I do do that, and look it the next morning, but I’m finding that most of the time I make half-hearted starts but soon give up and just hit the sack; I am, after all, pretty exhausted after screaming at kids. That’s fine and sensible, but unfortunately I haven’t been compensating by writing replies in the morning instead, so I have a huge backlog now.
As I type this I realize that that’s because I’m still stuck in the mindset of a newbie blogger, finding it difficult to spend as much or even more time replying to comments as researching and writing posts, especially if I’m in an inspirational buzz after drinking my morning coffee(s). But if I don’t I’ll end up just like those bloggers I complain about, so my sincere apologies to all of you that I’ve seemingly ignored, and as soon as I finish this post I’ll get onto dealing with that backlog, and always try to respond to comments within 24 hours from now on. If that sometimes means that I can’t post when I planned, so be it.
( Image by monkeyc.net )
Writing Style
Despite what I’ve said about doing little things to a blog to make people interested almost despite the content, strangely it’s only been relatively recently that it’s occurred to me that some people do actually read what I write, and that I need to take that into account. My natural blog-writing style is probably this, which I was in hysterics writing and still laugh at rereading now, but which unfortunately isn’t well suited to the kinds of topics I write about now.
As those topics become more cerebral, I’ve (again) only just realized that I need to make a big change in the way in the way I write them. Previously I’d typed everything into the tiny WordPress version 2.5 visual editor window, editing and previewing the post sometime up to 30 times as I go along for sure, but still, nothing like my MA essays, sometimes on much the same subjects and which more and more of my blog posts are beginning to resemble (ish), albeit without footnotes.
For those, I would generally do all my research first, make very detailed plans, begin to type the essay on MS Word where everything’s easy to see all at once, make connections and realize things as I did so which necessitated going back and change the plans completely, do half of it and print all that out, edit it till like you wouldn’t believe, sometime later work on the second half, combine them somehow…and only much later would I have an actual essay. It worked: I generally got A’s and B’s as a student. But I’ve only just started doing that for the blog, meaning that there’s a lot of posts there that look pretty, are full of academic words, and that I personally learned a great deal in the process of writing, but…man…I look back at them and cringe. I really should have resisted posting them straight after I finished writing them.

That includes some posts which people said they liked, and I hate to unintentionally sound patronizing to them for doing so. Let me avoid that by putting it this way: I never used to pay much attention to old posts at all, but then I started to get more and more comments on them months later, and some of the negative ones could have been avoided simply by providing clearer explanations and a better structure and so forth. Also, as I’ll explain, I’ve recently offered to write articles for some expat magazines, but once my proposals have been accepted and I’ve gone back to the old posts of mine that inspired them, thinking that all that’s required is changing a few lines here and there and removing the links…I’ve realized that they’re completely unacceptable. Partially because they’re very different media, partially because they lack things which my generally intelligent and knowledge readers already know and/or that I’ve already discussed…but mostly, because like I said, I’ve only just started to write with readers in mind.
Hmmm, maybe that doesn’t deal with me sounding patronizing. Oh hell…I don’t know. Not everything I write has been bad, and you’re allowed to like it! But I do personally think that I need to do a lot of work on the clarity, length, and interest and relevance to readers of my posts; my ultimate plan is, after all, to write for money, and while I’m slowly but steadily getting closer to that goal it’s still some way off yet.
Future Plans
Ironically probably the most concise part of this post, but if anything writing it has helped me to prioritize and narrow them down all the more:
Statistics:
Despite their ultimate irrelevance like I said, 80% of 2000 visitors reading the blog everyday obviously helps to achieve all my other blogging goals much better than 80% of 1000 visitors a day does. And although there’ll be a natural ceiling for this blog like I said, it’s hard to know where that ceiling is exactly because so few Korea bloggers make their stats public. For that reason I’ve started using SiteMeter as of the 18th of June so that bloggers inclined to do so can compare themselves against me, and eventually it’s averages will come in line with the reality. Meanwhile, here are the stats of The Marmot’s Hole and DramaBeans, the only two Korea blogs I know of that also do.
Not having much more than those to go on, then I’ll aim for 2500 daily visitors by this time next year. No, really, I think it’s quite possible and realistic. I’d be very surprised if at least 1500-2000 of the Marmot’s Hole’s visitors, for instance, didn’t arrive there solely because Robert has five years of material for search engines to latch onto (which newer blogs obviously lack). That isn’t a comment on the quality of his blog, it’s just a statement of fact. Still, that doesn’t mean that my planned jump won’t be quite a challenge, especially with my second daughter arriving in October.
Of course, what I’d really like to know is how many visitors the Scribblings of the Metropolitician gets and aim for that instead. After all, it would be very patronizing to readers to pretend that I’m not trying to emulate it in many ways.
Subjects:
I’m very happy to hear what readers would more and/or less of, otherwise I’ll probably keep to much the same subjects as I already am. With one important exception: I’m also going to start looking at all things related to Koreans in Australia and New Zealand, and those countries’ larger relations to Korea too.
When all is said and done, I’ll probably be returning to New Zealand in the next five years or six years or so for my daughters’ sakes, and once I’m there my most realistic chance of a semi-interesting and well-paying job, involving frequent travel to Korea, would be working for a company heavily involved in trading with Korea. And there’s no better medium than a blog to both become an expert in that field and become known for being one too.

( Source. New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark and Korean Actress Ha Ji-won (하지원), who studied English in New Zealand for a year. One of those lucky ladies has had the good fortune to see me half-naked from less than a metre away, and not only that but also when I was seriously buff, pumped, and had delicious sweat running down my pecs and abs too )
That may not sound interesting to the 99% of you that are not from Australia or New Zealand, but I’ll always relate them to wider issues of comparative immigration policies, Pacific trade, and identity issues of Korean emigrants and so forth, so other countries will get a lot of mention too. In a nutshell, if you like the stuff on the blog already, then you’ll like those posts too.
James Turnbull™
So, other than those minor changes really, the purpose of this blog will still primarily be for me to make like-minded friends, to network, to show to future employers how *cough* clever and knowledgeable I am and so ultimately get that fabled non-ESL job. Sorry if that sounds a little selfish, but I did warn you about the honesty. And I don’t think it makes me somehow less noble than bloggers who write just for fun.
And actually this blog will continue even after I do get that job, for I find it fun too. A few years ago, I picked up Stephen King’s autobiography, and in it he writes that unless you’re already writing as often as possible for the sheer pleasure of it, albeit with your dreams of becoming a famous author in the back of your mind, then you’ll simply never be a writer. I read that in 2006, and realised right than and there that my supposed dream of becoming a writer – one which virtually all BA graduates share – would only ever be precisely that, as I never actually did put pen to paper. But now, in 2008?
My job is pointless, repetitive, and an insult to my intelligence, but it does give me long hours to myself sitting at my desk. I don’t even have classes on many days, but nevertheless still have to be seen at my desk for most of 2:30 to 9:30. Yes, that pretty much does say it all about the mentality of the place, most expats with F2 visas would chafe at the restrictions for additional employment, and so I would quit were I not making a respectable amount of money for 32 year-old English teacher in Korea (albeit increasingly not a 32 year-old back home). But I do so I won’t, and in many ways the hours are a blessing really. And because all the constant meetings and announcements and so forth don’t apply to me, then usually I just arrive, plug in the laptop, ignore everything and everyone else and get to work on this blog. Frequently I’ll get so in the zone that I’ll suddenly realize with a start that four hours have passed and that I quickly need to prepare my classes, let alone eat dinner (or even lunch).
I love and am amazed how I can lose myself in it so. In all seriousness, it gives me a sense on an almost palpable and spiritual level that this is what I ought to be doing with my life…suddenly having to stop writing and being a clown for a few hours feels so jarring and like such an affront, much like the way you feel when you’re watching a beautiful and moving scene in a movie and then suddenly advertisements start screaming in your face.
With that in mind, from now on I’ll be spending much more time working towards not only writing for magazines, academic journals, and presenting papers at conferences but getting paid for doing so too; this blog will just be one block in that dream I am building as it were. As will becoming fluent in Korean too, as I’ve spent too much time on this blog rather than studying that (obviously much more useful), and with my next daughter arriving in nearly three months than I’m running out of time.
And on that note I’m looking forward to making a fresh start, especially as I type this on a Monday morning. A whole new week, pregnant with possibilities…sigh. Life is good.

( Source )



















You horrible man! I’ll bet you stole that Calvin graphic from my website!
http://www.spunangel.com/2008/02/snow-at-landfall.html
Coincidence? I think not.
Seriously, happy blog-birthday and please keep it up. Blogs like yours and Rob’s help keep me stay sane out here in Daejeon.
Sorry about that. I found it in a folder on my desktop, but then I’ve been reading your blog since well before February so I probably did originally find it there. Consider it attributed!
Happy Birthday! Like I said earlier, I always thought your blog was older than that.
I haven’t made my blog stats public, mostly b/c I’m embarassed by them. Lately I’ve been averaging around 400 unique visits a day, up from 250 – 300 a few weeks ago. Still haven’t hit the fabled 1,000 a day, but I’m happy where I’m at. Like you brought up, I’d rather have quality rather than quantity. Unless I’m being linked to by another blogger, a good portion of my hits are coming off image search results for the Wonder GIrls or Soulja Boy, both of whom I mentioned in passing in November. I enjoy getting hits for Jeollanam-do related stuff, and would ultimately like to do that more than just news and commentary.
As far as technorati goes . . . it has its limits. I mean, there only so many K-blogs out there, and it doesn’t take very long to get linked to by all of them. It’s always interesting to see who else is linking to me. One of my busiest days was when The Big Lead linked to me and brought a few hundreds hits in a matter of hours.
Thanks for the kind words, as always. I recommend you pick your spots when you go to the media, and perhaps find better outlets for your opinons, because I’m currently in pretty big trouble regarding the Gwangju News article and my latest KT piece. I’ve been dressed down at work several times, including at a big meeting just now, and I expect the cold shoulder treatment will continue for a while. While I think I’ve had a few more reactions from technorati than you, that’s just b/c I write more news stuff. You seem to be better respected for your research writing, a far more admirable pursuit than reading newspapers.
Happy birthday!
Happy Birthday, GN!
Thanks guys. Brian, it’s a pity to hear what happened to you, although I’d have to admit that it begs many questions, and everyone’s eagerly anticipating your next post on the netizen attacks especially. As I’m sure you know, I’ve repeatedly said equally critical and/or easily misconstrued things about Koreans on the blog, and while I’m sure that I’ll face the wrath of netizens eventually, like you said I’ve largely avoided it through not really commenting about recent news much. The average length of my posts probably helps too, ensuring that blogs and magazine articles like your own make far more convenient targets.
I won’t shy away from the English-language media here though, because: a) there’s many other outlets for writing available here, especially for someone without so much as an MA; b) a mere blog, no matter how many stats it’s getting, doesn’t pad out the writing resume much; and c) I’m fortunate in having an F2 Visa and a job I’m in no way attached to, which does leave one feeling rather cocky. But still, I’ll heed your advice, and will stick to non-news items until I’m a bit better established in that department. Well actually I’d already planned to…great minds thinking alike and all.
I truly enjoy your blog. Your posts are always interesting, and spot on IHO. Our blog is complete mindless crap, but then it is meant to be. Someday it may evolve, but more likely it will die a slow death when we sober up and tire of it.
Good Luck to you Sir!
Thanks again. Our blogs weren’t all that dissimilar a year ago…okay, maybe not mindless crap, but there was still quite a bit of crap on it nevertheless…and in many ways I regret that I always have to think twice about I’m writing these days.
LOL,
since I stole it from Mr. Watterson, I don’t think I have a legitimate gripe. ;-)
Do we have to get the blog a gold ring or something?
Well if you feel that that would be appropriate, don’t let me stop you…
Congrats on your blogs birthday. The site is doing quite well and I enjoy reading it.
I use Awstats to measure my sites stats which is provided by my Bluehost webhost provider which prides itself in being extremely accurate stat service that was also recommended in the blogging for dummies book. I do periodic roundup of in detail stats on my site for visitors to see how the blog is doing. The last one I did was in April:
http://rokdrop.com/2008/05/06/rok-drop-stats-for-april-2008/
My stats have continued to improve since then but I haven’t been able to reach the level I was at with my old Lycos Tripod site I used until I got my own host and changed over to WordPress. However, that may be because my stat tracker was not accurate. I was using Bravenet to track stats and still have it as my counter at the bottom of my page but its stats are inflated and not the same as what Awstats shows, so that is why I use Awstats to make my periodic blog stat postings.
I think with stats they are some what important but I think the big thing is the quality of people visiting your site. I could post pictures of celebrities every day and get more page views then I do now but that isn’t audience I’m looking for.
Also I recommend getting your own webhost provider. Yes it will affect your stats because of losing the postings archived in Google but it will not effect the core audience you interact with because they will just re-bookmark the site. I’m just getting near back to my stats from my Lycos Tripod site but I like the freedom a Webhost providers gives me to do what I want with the blog. It does take a little bit more work though to learn simple CSS styling and what not but overall I have enjoyed it.
Also I have to comment about other K-bloggers not replying to comments and emails. As far as comments I can understand sometimes not replying just because of the sheer quantity of comments left. I know there are times I can’t read all my comments or I might be away for a week and leave some auto-posts and people comment but I don’t reply because I’m not there. The Marmot’s Hole gets so many comments I don’t think there is anyway Robert can keep up with them all there. So I can understand not being able to reply to all comments.
However with e-mail I return e-mails from people with questions though it may take time to reply just because I am simply not able to check my email because I may be gone for a couple of weeks doing Army training. However, I do eventually answer them when I get back. I have sent e-mails to other K-bloggers and have always had replies even though some of them have been late because they to are busy and are flooded with emails at times. However, if the email is hate mail I don’t bother responding and I assume other K-bloggers probably do the same thing.
Anyway keep up the great work and if it was Helen Clark that saw you half naked I don’t know if that is a thing to brag about? ;-)
Thanks, and I appreciate your advice. Despite what I say in the post, some days I’m still virtually crawling up the wall thinking about whether to go self-hosting or not. Of course, there are numerous small advantages to doing so, most of which revolve around the ability to use javascript and to help give the blog a more distinctive and professional look, the latter of which is not easy when even bloggers in your own blogroll use exactly the same theme (great minds think alike and all). And the biggest overall advantage would be in having full control of the blog, quite important when this is my primary means of representing myself to the world; I may well regret not having gone self-hosting much earlier when I suddenly become (relatively) famous and people flock to it.
I’m sure I will go self-hosting eventually, but probably not for another six months or a year from now at least. I’d have no problems losing those “visitors” looking for porn and only retaining my core audience after the switch, but I’m only just beginning to get linked to and noticed for what I’ve written on Korean women especially, and I’d like a critical mass of material up there and to have established more of a reputation for myself in that field before I lost my ranking in the search engines. Which I guess is just a long way of saying I’d like my core audience to be a little bigger first.
In the meantime, although I’ve heard repeatedly that it’s no big deal, making the shift to wordpress.org still looks like a hassle and a little scary, and while wordpress.com does have an annoying habit of suddenly imposing changes full of bugs on users unannounced, having millions of users all too happy to point them out and complain does mean that they get fixed quickly. It gives a nice secure feeling when you just want to concentrate on writing really, and especially when your own laptop is still full of viruses after 4 weeks of trying to get rid of them.
Finally, I was probably too vague, and a little harsh, when I said that I don’t want to become like “some big name Korea bloggers that virtually ignore all comments and emails”. Of course, I too find the sheer number of comments daunting sometimes and simply don’t have the time or energy to reply.
To be more specific, I meant that I don’t want to end up treating them like Michael Hurt seems to, as he has quite a reputation for sometimes responding at length to comments and emails, and usually quite politely and informatively too, but then virtually not responding at all for months at a time.
Or like Robert Koehler does either. I don’t have any problem with the number of comments he does or doesn’t reply to himself, and he’s mentioned how tired he is after blogging for so long, which I can appreciate already. But I don’t like how he allows blatantly racist and/or sexist trolls to provoke everyone unimpeded. For sure, the tabloid culture of the blog can be appealing, and with regards to trolls he frequently mentions libertarianism with regards to that, which is cool, and of course at the end of the day it’s his blog and he can do whatever he wants with it too.
But when you read threads like this then it’s difficult not to be cynical and conclude that the the trolls are allowed to stay for…well, for what? I was going to say hits, but considering how the topics he covers are frquently quite heavy, but that the trolls put off people with brains for the most part, then it begs the question as to what Robert’s aims with the blog are. I’m genuinely curious as to what keeps him going, and come to think of it Korea-bloggers explaining their aims seems to be the exception rather than the rule.
Anyway that’s all a bit of a rant and off-topic sorry. But then a Delta(?) or Epsilon(?) blogger like myself is always thinking about those at the head of the pack!
Just curious, and I have no idea how much effort this would take b/c I’m thinking outloud, but couldn’t you get your own site, copy and paste your articles over there, all while keeping this one up and running? You’d keep your readership here, I think, while acclimating them to your new address, and you’d probably get hits to that site off of google searches, so it wouldn’t be like completely starting over.
Actually it’s much much easier than copying and pasting hundreds of posts. You save them all as one file, and later you use the software in your new blog to open it and they all get backdated and in the right places and so on. So the content of the blog would be 100% exactly the same as the old one.
When you do that though, you have to delete all the content of your old blog, because search engine spiders noticing the same content with the same timestamp assumes it’s reading two splogs and so shunts them very far down in the rankings. But after having deleted the content of the old blog I still wouldn’t start in the same position as before in searches. This site has a google page rank of 4 because of all the searches for pictures of women in bikinis in old posts, which means that no matter what the topic searched for it beats sites with similar content that have lower page ranks. But if I started with the same content on a new site, my page rank would be at zero. It can take up to a year to get it back to the same level as before, even if the same number of people visit.
Oh, and I’m curious about your sitemeter. Did you opt to hide from the public the “referrals”? I’m just curious where your guests are coming from. Google searches? Other blogs?
I didn’t opt to hide it. But because WordPress.com doesn’t allow Javascript then sitemeter and other stats programs can’t record referrals. But seeing as how 80% of my visitors look for five seconds or less, you can imagine that the vast majority come from search engines.
I’m stuck with the crappy one on WordPress.com then. But if you like, I can still give a more detailed list of my top referrers and so on in a quick separate post. Other readers that are also bloggers are probably interested too.